NEW - IDC WebcastFree E-NewslettersRSS Feeds | Site Map
Security Resource CentreBusiness Value of TechnologyMunicipal Centre
SearchSearch
Tips
Policy
Slice by Program

Opinion: 10 broken technology ideas

By: John Brandon, Computerworld (U.S.)(Mar 06, 2008 06:00:00)

Previous page: Broken technologies

6. Web 2.0
For the past two years, the promise of the Semantic Web -- a concept where the Web is smarter and lets you tag information for better searchability -- has reached a crescendo that is finally coming down to earth.

I believe there is no clear definition of Web 2.0 or any sites that fit easily into that box. Instead, Web 1.0 is in a constant state of evolution. Imagine Amazon.com in its infancy -- over the past 10 years, it has been updated with hundreds of new features as Web technology has steadily advanced.

What I'm hoping for is a whole new framework for the Web: a wholesale HTML replacement, something like AJAX (Asynchronous JavaScript and XML) that's faster and more reliable. Or, I'd like to see sites like Pageflakes expand even more so that Web 2.0 dies altogether and gives way to Internet widgets running on a true Internet operating system.

7. Electronic books
A promising technology, or a snake-oil sales pitch? E-books like the Amazon Kindle and Sony eReader could eventually reduce our reliance on paper books. I must admit the crisp 120DPI screens look remarkably like printed material.

In some ways, the Web is a gigantic e-book with an endless amount of information -- even if some of it is unreliable (see Wikipedia.org). Yet, nothing beats a printed book: you can find your place instantly with a dog-ear, it's practically disposable, you can loan it to anyone, and it causes very little eye strain.

Yes, you can load one of 90,000 books on the Kindle and check your e-mail in between chapters of the latest Stephen King novel. But before an e-book reader becomes a major hit with consumers, it must cost about the same as a real book. I'd like a throwaway e-book that's a plastic sheet with electronic ink (like the newspapers in Minority Report ) and costs about $30.

8. Internet voting
I like the idea of Internet voting because the easier you make the process, the more people who will vote. Right now, the concept is in a preliminary stage because fingerprint readers or some other form of biometrics hasn't become ubiquitous or foolproof.

I have noticed that just about every enterprise laptop has a fingerprint reader. In the same way that Hollywood studios don't trust the Internet for delivering movies unless they are crippled with digital rights management, voting also needs some extra precautions to ward off fraud.

The idea will finally work once all displays are multitouch (which might be sooner than we think), facial recognition is common and secure, and there is some way of encrypting the connection to assuage any doubts.

9. Video blogs
My main issue with video blogs is that they don't seem well suited for the Web. I'd watch "Rocketboom" , "Mahalo Daily" and "WebbAlert" every day if I had the time.

Often, with WebbAlert, I scan through the links -- it usually has a really good summary of the previous day and posts in my RSS reader before just about anyone else -- instead of watching the video blog.

The Web is made for instant information (see Facebook, Wikipedia, etc.), and I have a hard time discerning how a video blog is really that different from a 2-minute update on G4 or CNN.

Yes, there's the idea that a video blog has a "long tail" -- many continuing views of a video after its initial post -- suited for any taste, but the farther you go out on the tail, the lower its quality seems to be.

Where is this all going? I'd like to see satellite television providers like Dish Network and DirecTV offer more-flexible plans. I'd watch a video blog station for 10 minutes if it could hold my attention over breakfast and The Wall Street Journal.

10. Flexible keyboards
Flexible, foldable keyboards like the Brando or the Eleksen ElekTex sound like a good replacement for a standard keyboard and could help mobile users type faster when traveling with smart phones.

In practice, it's almost impossible to type fast on these roll-away models. Is there a way to improve on a standard keyboard? Microsoft and Logitech International keep trying, adding extra buttons and features. (I have settled on the Microsoft Wireless Laser Keyboard 6000 V2 with its slight key curvature.)

I doubt we will be typing on multitouch screens any faster, judging by my speed on the iPhone. Speech recognition, even if it understood every word perfectly, still makes it hard to edit your mistakes. The Laser Keyboard is hinting at a true evolution: Eventually, all keyboards will become more tactile, with more responsive keys, a more ergonomic feel -- and someone may figure out how to make them fold up.

John Brandon is a freelance writer and book author who worked as an IT manager for 10 years.

Related content:

The 50 greatest gadgets of the past 50 years

10 hot public sector IT trends for 2007

Bookmark on:del.icio.us| Digg it| Furl| Google| Technorati| StumbleIt| Yahoo!

Have something to say about this article?
Add a new commentLetter to the Editor
Find an inappropriate comment? You can notify the moderator by clicking the Report an innapropriate comment icon.
ADD A COMMENT
Name:*Your email address will not appear online and will be used only in the event that the editor wishes to contact you personally for additional comment.
City:
Email:
Title:*
Comment:*
* required fields
Blog Spotlight: Sandford Borins
Sandford Borins

As Professor of Strategic Management at the University of Toronto, Sandford Borins brings InterGovWorld.com readers exclusive insights into how and why the public sector is changing. You'll find new perspectives and questions, observations and objectives, lessons and answers. Cover to Cover, the blog by Prof. Sandford Borins, appears every Thursday.

Inside Cover to Cover

Unified Communications
Data Defence

Unity is a word often heard in the public sector, with myriad agencies and departments looking to foster collective thinking around some of today's most pressing issues. The word, however, doesn't usually get mentioned in the same breath as technology. That's a situation, though, that might soon be changing, thanks to a new software platform known as unified communications.

Inside the latest issue of CGR

More Resources
Driving innovation through effective service management
This white paper discusses how a service-oriented governance framework can help ensure that IT decisions are consistent with business vision, values and strategies-and that IT delivers maximum value to the business. Complimentary with registration.
IT Service Management Solutions and the service desk
This white paper presents the capabilities of IBM Tivoli CCMDB, and describes how Tivoli CCMDB extends the value of the service desk and integrates other essential ITIL processes in support of IBM Service Management. Complimentary with registration.
Info-Tech Research Note: WAN Optimization Tools worth the investment
Multi-site enterprises experiencing WAN bandwidth demand growth and struggling to maintain acceptable application performance should evaluate WAN optimization technology immediately. WAN optimization appliances can dramatically improve inter-site WAN performance, reduce bandwidth requirements, and allow for server centralization. For many enterprises a positive ROI can be achieved in less than a year. Download this research note now. Complimentary with registration.
Advertisement

2007 Salary Calculator
Knowledge Centres at a Glance
White Papers
read more white papers
New blog entries
Thoughts of the day
This week's top stories
Most popular stories of the week
Readers write back
Comments from Intergovworld readers
Government to government
Inside the public sector machine
Government to business
P3: Public-private partnerships
Government to citizen
e-Government service transformation
Blogs
Browse Blogs By:
WiFi Hot Spot Finder
Upload Centre
Upload Your Documents
Contribute and share with your peers by uploading:
- Initiative updates
- White Papers
- Job Links
- Events
- Other
Download Centre
Most popular downloads:
Download More Documents
Download:
- Initiative updates
- White Papers
- Job Links
Subscription Services
Manage your InterGovWorld.com account!
Change your account information, password, e-mail address, and existing e-newsletter subscriptions.
Site Feedback Survey
Tell us what you think of InterGovWorld.com!
FUN SurveyFUN Survey
Take the one-minute Family Unit Networking survey!
IT Salary Survey IT Salary Survey
Take the IT Salary Survey '06 Today
Career Resources
InterGovWorld provides links to resources for government job seekers and current employees, including: current job postings, job search strategies, career options and training, and employee rights, provided by all levels of government from everywhere across Canada.

Public Service Commission of Canada
Service Canada
Jobs in Canada
Service Canada
Public Service Human Resources Management Agency of Canada